The club that turned me down twice


Hey Reader,

Stoke have interviewed me twice.

I didn't get either job.

Twice I went through the whole thing. Twice I got the no.

Here's the part I didn't expect.

The head of football operations there still messages me.

Not about a job for me. About other people.

We've got someone here, can you help them.

There might be an opportunity coming up.

I've never worked a day for that club.

And they're still one of the more useful relationships I have in the game.

That took me a long time to understand, so I'll say it plainly.

The rejection isn't the end of the process.

It's often the start of the relationship.

Think about what actually happens in an interview.

You sit in a room with people who work in football. For an hour, sometimes longer, they get to know how you think.

That doesn't get deleted when they pick someone else.

You are now a person they've met. Someone whose thinking they've seen up close.

There was only ever one job. There were never only two outcomes.

One of our Recruitment Room members had the same thing happen.

Freddie almost didn't apply to Sheffield United. He didn't feel ready.

One of our mentors told him to go for it anyway.

He reached the final interview.

He didn't get it.

Then Sheffield United started sending him job adverts.

Because of the impression he left in the process.

He's a recruitment analyst at Cambridge United now. Under a year ago he'd never worked a day in football.

He'll tell you the Sheffield near-miss was one of the most useful things that happened to him.

Not because it worked out. It didn't.

But it was proof he was closer than he thought.

And it was live practice, under real pressure, at no cost.

Now before you say "but I'm not even getting interviews yet" - that's the same problem wearing a different coat.

Almost nobody feels ready when they apply.

Freddie doesn't meet every requirement for the job he holds right now.

The advice I give everyone is to apply at six or seven out of ten. Not ten out of ten.

Ten out of ten never comes.

I should be honest about the rest of it too.

Football hiring is slow. Clubs communicate badly. Getting ghosted after a final stage is normal, and it has happened to me.

None of that is a reflection of you.

Stop treating an application as a lottery ticket you either win or lose.

Start treating it as a room you get to be in.

Prepare properly. Turn up as someone worth remembering. Be gracious when the no comes, because it will come plenty of times.

Then stay in touch.

Because football is a small industry, and it runs on sliding doors.

The people making decisions today are somewhere else in eighteen months.

The one who turned you down becomes the one who thinks of you.

An opportunity that leads nowhere now doesn't mean it leads nowhere ever.

Two clubs told me no.

One of them still opens doors for me.

Go and get told no by someone worth knowing.

Liam

Not getting the interviews yet?

The Football Recruitment Roadmap is my free, step-by-step guide to breaking into football. The exact route, laid out.

→ Get the free roadmap

Doors to the Recruitment Room are closed until October, but you can apply to join now. Here's the link to change your career.

Any questions, just reply. I read everything.

Liam Henshaw

Join The Recruitment Room: sign up here​

Football Recruitment Roadmap: read here​

More Writing & Advice: read here​

Podcasts I've Done: watch here​

Unit 145786, PO Box 7169, Poole, Dorset BH15 9EL
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Liam Henshaw

I am a data analyst and scout working in professional football. Subscribe and join over 5,000+ newsletter readers every week!

Read more from Liam Henshaw

Hey Reader, I had a Recruitment Room onboarding call yesterday with a new member. He's a data scientist with a master's in AI. Technically he's miles ahead of where I was when I started, and probably ahead of most people who want to get into football. A week before the call he'd put a short post on LinkedIn about a computer vision project from his master's, and it got a lot of reactions from people in the industry. He picked up connections with chief scouts and data scientists at Bundesliga...

Hey Reader, Craig Bradley is a first team scout at Derby County. Five years ago he was a retail supervisor in his forties, with no football on his CV at all. He ran a session inside the Recruitment Room on Thursday, and one bit is worth telling you about. The way he got his first club role. He didn't apply for it. He noticed something. He lived in Plymouth. Plymouth Argyle had scouts at every grassroots game he went to. He had never once seen one from Exeter City. So he went to Exeter with...

Hey Reader, I had a call last week with someone about joining the Recruitment Room. He's getting paid, inside a first division club, working on scouting and recruitment for the first team. He's building his own scouting application. At the end of it, he asked me a question. He writes his code with AI. And he wanted to know whether that counts against him. And this is a question I hear a lot. If coding has become easy, does it still count for anything? So let me answer it properly. Of course...